Consultant vs Contractor: What’s the Difference?

November 24, 2023

Contractors and consultants are integral to the success of many IT projects in Australia. As strong growth in IT services is forecasted for Australia in the coming years, with contracting also becoming more common, it’s worthwhile exploring how consultants and contractors are currently engaged by organisations.


Whilst both IT contractors and consultants provide specialised IT services to clients, they have a number of key differences across the work they carry out, the payment they receive and the expectations for what they can deliver.


In this blog, we’ll delve into the roles of contractors and consultants and highlight their similarities and differences in IT projects.

What is an IT Contractor?

IT contractors are professionals hired for a specific project or for a predetermined period. They provide specialised skills and expertise that an organisation doesn’t have in-house. We recently shared a guide about contracting.


The ‘contract’ of an IT contractor is usually full time, but only for a set period (i.e. 6 months) – however, a contract may also be extended if both parties agree.


IT contractors can be self-employed or work through an agency. This means they don’t have the same entitlements as a full-time employee might. However, this also carries the added benefit of having more control over their schedules, projects and contract negotiation.


Contracting in IT is often compensated on a project-based fee or daily rate, reflecting the temporary and project-oriented nature of their work engagements. This structure allows them to adapt to varying project requirements and align their compensation with the complexity and duration of the projects they undertake.


What is an IT Consultant?

An IT consultant is a highly skilled professional who provides specialised advice and expertise to organisations, offering insights, solutions, and recommendations to address specific challenges or improve the overall IT infrastructure within a company.


Unlike contractors, IT consultants are typically engaged on a project-by-project basis or for strategic initiatives rather than for a set period of time.


IT consultants may also operate as independent contractors, which is why the two types of roles can be sometimes confused with each other. Consultants, however, may also work through consulting firms or within dedicated consulting departments of larger organisations. IT consultants can be compensated based on project fees, hourly rates, or a retainer.


Key Differences Between Contractors & Consultants


Now that we’ve covered the basics of what it means to be an IT contractor and consultant, let’s examine a few more key differences between the two roles. It’s important to note that consultants can operate as contractors — meaning they may have the same benefits and limitations of contracting. However, their role is ultimately more specialised than that which is necessitated by the term ‘contractor’.


1. Nature of Engagement


Contractors:

 IT contractors are typically engaged for specific projects or predetermined durations, focusing on completing predefined tasks within a project’s scope. Their work is often project-centric and often involves a hands-on approach, aiming to meet established goals within their contract’s timeline.


Consultants:

IT consultants, on the other hand, engage in a more advisory role. Their involvement is not necessarily limited to a specific project or timeline. Instead, they provide expert guidance and recommendations to clients to help solve problems, improve processes, or achieve strategic IT objectives. Consultants work on a broader, more strategic level, addressing overall IT frameworks and business strategies.


2. Specialisation


Contractors:

Contractors possess specialised skills and expertise within a particular domain of IT, making them suitable for specific tasks or projects. Their specialisation allows them to more efficiently complete tasks within their area of expertise than an in-house employee may be able to, making contractors an attractive option to employers.


Consultants:

Consultants also possess specialised knowledge, however this is often at a broader level than an individual contracting in IT. They often have expertise in multiple IT domains, enabling them to provide comprehensive solutions that align with an organisation’s broader goals. Their work is not just confined to a specific task or domain, it also involves strategies for organisational optimisation.


3. Responsibilities & Focus


Contractors:

Contractors focus on delivering tangible outputs within a project’s defined scope. Their responsibilities centre around completing the tasks assigned to them, often with a specific end product or milestone in mind.


Consultants:

Consultants have a holistic focus on the client’s overall IT strategy and operations. Their responsibilities include understanding the client’s business, identifying areas for improvement, recommending appropriate solutions, and aiding in implementation. Ultimately, consultants are more concerned with the long-term success of an organisation than a contractor may be.


4. Duration & Flexibility


Contractors:

Contractors work on a temporary basis, often on a project-by-project or timed contract. Whilst contractors have the flexibility to choose projects and negotiate contracts, their engagements are typically more structured within the project’s timeline than a consultant’s may be.


Consultants:

Consulting engagements can vary in duration, often lasting longer than typical contracting roles. Consultants have greater flexibility in shaping the duration and terms of their engagements, allowing for ongoing or extended relationships with clients beyond a specific project.


5. Compensation


Contractors:

IT contractors are compensated based on a project basis or an hourly rate. Their payment is directly tied to the completion of specific tasks or deliverables within the project scope. Contractors’ pay often reflects the complexity and urgency of the project – they ultimately negotiate their rates based on their expertise and market demand. Many contractors choose to work with contract recruitment agencies that can provide them with steady stream of assignments to work on.


Consultants:

IT consultants typically charge clients on a project or retainer basis. They negotiate their fees considering the value they bring to the client’s organisation. This value encompasses their expertise, strategic guidance, and the potential impact their suggestions make on the client’s operations. The payment structure for consultants can vary greatly, often involving a blend of upfront fees, ongoing retainer fees, and performance-based bonuses tied to achieving predetermined goals or milestones.


Conclusion

Understanding the key differences between the role of an IT contractor and consultant can help you determine how to position yourself for project-based work, based on your skill level and experience.


Still wondering which position best suits you – or simply looking for your next contract/consultant gig? Our team at Emanate Technology, as one of Australia’s best IT-focused contract recruitment agencies, possess unparalleled knowledge of the IT job market. We’re dedicated to understanding your unique talents, experiences, and career goals to match you with the best opportunities – so please don’t hesitate to contact us.

Two women are sitting in front of a laptop computer.
By Emanate Technology March 16, 2025
Understand what neurodiversity is and how the tech workforce is changing. Why is support important? And how to build inclusive tech teams in Australia.
A group of people are sitting at desks in an office having a meeting.
By Emanate Technology February 27, 2025
Your ultimate guide to tech and IT salaries in Australia. Uncover the highest-paying roles, regional variations, and insider tips to heighten your career and salary.
A man is sitting at a desk in front of a computer.
By Emanate Technology January 29, 2025
Craft a winning tech resume with AI-powered prompts. Get expert tips, examples, and optimise your CV for Australian job applications.
Two women are sitting at a table talking to each other.
By Emanate Technology December 18, 2024
Learn how to ask for a pay rise and increase your salary. Expert advice on preparing your case, negotiating effectively, and securing the pay increase.
Show More